|Year : 2015 | Volume
| Issue : 2 | Page : 79-84
Preperitoneal versus Lichtenstein tension-free hernioplasty for the treatment of bilateral inguinal hernia
Ahmed Rabae Talha MD, MRCS , Ahmed Shaaban, Rabie Ramadan
Department of Surgery, Medical Research Institute, Alexandria University, Alexandria, Egypt
|Date of Submission||15-Nov-2014|
|Date of Acceptance||07-Dec-2014|
|Date of Web Publication||23-Apr-2015|
Ahmed Rabae Talha
Department of Surgery, Medical Research Institute, Alexandria University, 165, Alhorreya Avenue, Hadara, 21561 Alexandria
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
Inguinal hernia is one of the most common diseases in the surgical setting. Bilateral inguinal hernia is present in 12% of patients and its treatment has been debated for long, sequential or simultaneous repair especially after tension-free repairs. We carried out this study to compare the Stoppa procedure with bilateral Lichtenstein hernioplasty for the treatment of bilateral inguinal hernia.
Materials and Methods
The study included 40 patients with bilateral inguinal hernias who were allocated randomly to two groups. Group A included 20 patients who were operated by bilateral Lichtenstein hernioplasty. Group B also included 20 patients who were operated by Stoppa repair. Recording of preoperative data (age, sex, BMI, comorbidity, smoking, and type of hernia), operative data (operative time and operative complications) and postoperative data (complications, pain, hospital stay, return to normal daily activities, chronic groin pain, and recurrence) was performed for each patient in the study. Patients were assessed at 7 days, and 1, 6, and 12 months after the procedure at the outpatient clinic.
All patients were men. There was no statistically significant difference between both groups in preoperative data. The Stoppa procedure took a significantly shorter time than bilateral Lichtenstein repair; the mean operative time for Stoppa and bilateral Lichtenstein was 39.0 ± 5.15 and 62.25 ± 7.95 min, respectively. Postoperative pain scoring using the visual analogue score at 12 h postoperatively was significantly lower with the use of the Stoppa procedure than bilateral Lichtenstein repair, but there was no statistically significant difference between both groups in postoperative pain scoring at 24 h and 7 days postoperatively. No significant difference was detected between both groups in operative complications, postoperative complications, hospital stay, return to normal daily activities, and chronic groin pain. No recurrence was detected in any of the patients after 1 year of follow-up.
Bilateral inguinal hernias can be repaired simultaneously in the same setting safely and effectively without an increase in morbidity or recurrence rate. The Stoppa procedure can be a good alternative to bilateral Lichtenstein repair for the treatment of bilateral inguinal hernia, with comparable outcome.
Keywords: bilateral, hernia repair, inguinal hernia, Lichtenstein, Stoppa
|How to cite this article:|
Talha AR, Shaaban A, Ramadan R. Preperitoneal versus Lichtenstein tension-free hernioplasty for the treatment of bilateral inguinal hernia. Egypt J Surg 2015;34:79-84
|How to cite this URL:|
Talha AR, Shaaban A, Ramadan R. Preperitoneal versus Lichtenstein tension-free hernioplasty for the treatment of bilateral inguinal hernia. Egypt J Surg [serial online] 2015 [cited 2019 Sep 17];34:79-84. Available from: http://www.ejs.eg.net/text.asp?2015/34/2/79/155715
| Introduction|| |
Inguinal hernia is one of the most frequently performed operations in general surgery , . It occurs in ~1.5% of the general population  . Most inguinal hernias are unilateral and at the right side and only 12% of patients have bilateral inguinal hernias  . Simultaneous or sequential repair of bilateral hernias is still debatable , . For many years, it was believed that simultaneous repair of bilateral inguinal hernias could not be done because this approach may result in a high recurrence rate  . This idea is now being questioned with the emergence of the 'tension-free' techniques. Authors have described about 80 operative techniques for inguinal hernia repair since Bassini reported his procedure in 1887  . Surgeons continue to search for the optimum repair method with the least recurrence and least complications. The development of tension-free repairs made a huge breakthrough in hernia surgery. Placement of a mesh is required in all types of tension-free repair; the mesh may be placed through an open anterior, open posterior, or laparoscopic route. Multiple tension-free techniques are available now, which include the open anterior approach (onlay Lichtenstein patch, plug and patch), the open posterior approach (Stoppa, Kugel), and the closed posterior approach (laparoscopic)  . Simultaneous repair of bilateral inguinal hernias may have the advantages of patient satisfaction and lower costs because the patient is subjected to only one hospital admission, one anesthesia, and only one period of recovery is required  . This debate on the management of bilateral inguinal hernias led us to carry out our present study with the aim of comparing the Stoppa procedure with Lichtenstein tension-free hernioplasty for the management of bilateral inguinal hernia in terms of operative time, intraoperative complications, postoperative complications, postoperative pain, hospital stay, return to normal daily activities, chronic groin pain, and recurrence.
This is a prospective, randomized, controlled trial. The design involved 40 male patients with bilateral inguinal hernia scheduled for simultaneous repair of their bilateral hernias at the Department of Surgery, Medical Research Institute Hospital, Alexandria University. Patients were considered eligible after evaluation of clinical history, a thorough physical examination, blood chemistry, and radiological evaluation (ultrasonography of the abdomen and pelvis). Patients included in the study were divided into two groups: group A (underwent bilateral Lichtenstein tension-free hernioplasty) and group B (underwent Stoppa repair); patients with recurrent inguinal hernias and those undergoing emergency hernia repairs were excluded.
A specific informed consent form approved by our Institution's Ethics Committee had to be signed by the candidates before inclusion in the trial; this form included detailed information about the surgery, the expected complications, and possible recurrence.
To evaluate the incidence of recurrence and chronic groin pain in the two groups of patients.
- Perioperative parameters (operative time, intraoperative, and postoperative complications),
- Hospital stay,
- Postoperative pain scoring,
- Timing of return to normal daily activity, and
- Follow-up details.
Eligible patients were randomized into two groups: group A (underwent bilateral Lichtenstein tension-free hernioplasty) and group B (underwent Stoppa repair) using sealed opaque envelopes containing computer-generated random numbers. The randomization was performed 1 week before surgery during the preoperative assessment.
Spinal anesthesia was used routinely for all patients. Immediately preoperatively, every patient received 2 g cefatriaxone.
Lichtenstein tension-free hernioplasty 
A skin incision was made parallel to the inguinal ligament extending from about 1/2 inch above and lateral to the pubic tubercle to just below and medial to the anterior superior iliac spine. The indirect hernia sac was dissected, ligated, and sectioned using Vicryl 0 (Ethicon; Johnson & Johnson International, Sint-Stevens-Woluwe, Belgium). The large direct sacs were invaginated and plicated using Vicryl 2/0 (Ethicon; Johnson & Johnson International). A heavy prolene mesh of 6 × 11 cm (PMH, prolene mesh, polypropylene nonabsorbable synthetic mesh 6 × 11 cm, Ethicon; Johnson & Johnson International) was used in all cases. The mesh was fixed in place using interrupted polypropylene 2/0 (Ethicon Sutures, Cincinnati, Ohio, USA). The mesh was fixed to the inguinal ligament and the conjoint tendon starting from the pubic tubercle extending beyond the orifice of the internal ring.
The technique developed by Stoppa was used, with some modifications ,,, . For all patients, a pfenestiel incision was used as a standard, followed by vertical separation of both recti to enter the preperitoneal space. Blunt dissection of the preperitoneal space was performed. Dissection involved the retropubic space of Retzius, and reached the rectus abdominis muscle and epigastric vessels laterally, extending to the retroinguinal space. The spermatic cord and gonadal vessels were visualized. The superior pubic ramus, the obturator foramen, and iliac vessels were exposed. Direct hernias were identified and reduced. Large sacs were removed and ligated with a purse-string suture. Indirect sacs were divided, the proximal peritoneum was sutured, and the distal peritoneum was left in place attached to the cord. If indirect hernia was sliding, dissection of the sac from the cord structures was performed. Parietalization of the spermatic cord and gonadal vessels was performed by dissection of their peritoneal attachment. A prolene mesh (PMH, prolene mesh, polypropylene nonabsorbable synthetic mesh 30×30 cm; Ethicon; Johnson & Johnson International) was placed in the preperitoneal space. Fixation of the mesh was not required as the intra-abdominal pressure forces the mesh to lay flat between the peritoneum and the fascial layers.
Operative data of each patient were recorded with a focus on operative time and intraoperative complications. Postoperative data recording included assessment of postoperative pain, postoperative complications, hospital stay, time of returning to normal daily activities, chronic groin pain, and recurrence. For each patient, postoperative pain was assessed at 12, 24 h, and 7 days postoperatively using the visual analogue scale  .
All patients were followed at 7 days, and 1, 6, and 12 months after the operation at the outpatient clinic for assessment complications, pain, return to normal daily activities, chronic groin pain, and recurrence.
Statistical analysis was carried out using the statistical package for the social sciences, version 20 software (SPSS Inc., Chicago, Illinois, USA). Significance level was set at α = 0.05. Qualitative data were described using number and percent. Quantitative data were described using range (minimum and maximum), mean, SD, and median. Comparison between different groups in terms of categorical variables was performed using the χ2 -test. When more than 20% of the cells had an expected count lower than 5, correction for χ2 was performed using the Fisher's Exact test or Monte Carlo correction. For normally distributed data, comparisons between two independent population were performed using an independent t-test; comparisons between different periods using analysis of variance with repeated measures and post-hoc test were performed using Bonferroni adjustment. For abnormally distributed data, comparisons between two independent populations were performed using the Mann-Whitney test.
| Results|| |
The present study included 40 male patients with bilateral inguinal hernias who were allocated randomly to two groups. Group A included 20 patients who were operated by bilateral Lichtenstein tension-free hernioplasty. Group B also included 20 patients who were operated by Stoppa repair. All patients in the present study were men. There was no statistically significant difference between both groups in preoperative data (age, BMI, comorbidities, smoking, and type of hernia) ([Table 1]).
The operative time was significantly shorter in group B patients; it ranged between 30 and 50 min, with a mean of 39.0 ± 5.15 min, whereas in group A, it ranged between 50 and 75 min, with a mean of 62.25 ± 7.95 min, as shown in [Table 2]. There were no intraoperative complications (vascular or visceral injury) in either group.
Postoperative pain scoring measured by the visual analogue scale at 12 h postoperatively was significantly lower in group B patients, but there was no statistically significant difference between both groups in pain at 24 h and 7 days postoperatively ([Table 3]).
There was no statistically significant difference between both groups in postoperative complications, postoperative hospital stay, return to normal daily activities, and chronic groin pain ([Table 2]). No recurrence occurred in any patient after 1 year of follow-up in either group.
| Discussion|| |
For many years, it was believed that simultaneous repair of bilateral inguinal hernias should not be performed because this approach would cause increased postoperative complications (pain, wound complications, and recurrences)  . Today, it is known that the simultaneous repair of bilateral hernia is safe and effective.
The European Hernia Society elaborated guidelines for the treatment of bilateral inguinal hernias and recommended a one-stage procedure (Lichtenstein or laparoscopic)  . The Stoppa procedure can be another alternative for bilateral inguinal hernia treatment, but only for the surgeons familiar with it , . This led us to carry out this study to compare the Stoppa procedure with bilateral Lichtenstein hernioplasty for the treatment of bilateral inguinal hernias.
Malazgirt et al.  carried out a study on 45 patients with bilateral inguinal hernias (22 patients were operated by Stoppa and 23 patients were operated by bilateral Lichtenstein), and reported that Stoppa procedures took significantly shorter time than bilateral Lichtenstein repairs. They performed Stoppa repair under spinal anesthesia and Lichtenstein repair under either spinal or local anesthesia. In the present study, all procedures were performed under spinal anesthesia to avoid any bias in terms of postoperative pain scoring. Our results were comparable with those of Malazgirt et al.  in the operative time as the Stoppa procedure took a significantly shorter time than bilateral Lichtenstein repair. Gustavo et al.  carried out a study to evaluate simultaneous bilateral inguinal hernia repair by the Lichtenstein technique and reported a mean operative time of 113 ± 19.33 min, which was significantly longer than the mean operative time of bilateral Lichtenstein repair in the present study (62.25 ± 7.95 min). Gustavo et al.  did not exclude recurrent and complicated hernias; this may be an explanation for the prolonged operative time found in their study. Fernandez-Lobato et al.  carried out a large-scale study to evaluate Stoppa repair in bilateral inguinal hernia that involved 210 patients who underwent surgery for bilateral inguinal hernia from January 1995 to December 2003. They recorded that the operative time decreased significantly from 105 min in the first year to less than 61 min in 2001, with 73% of the cases operated in less than 60 min (P < 0.0001) and 62% in 2003. Stoppa et al.  described a mean operative time of 51 min. This duration is also shorter than that required in the bilateral Lichtenstein technique , . In the present study, the mean operative time for Stoppa repair was 39.0 ± 5.15 min, which is about 10 min less than what was reported by Stoppa because Stoppa and colleagues focused their study on complex and recurrent hernias and we excluded these cases from our study.
In our study, there was no significant difference between both groups in postoperative hospital stay, which was in agreement with the study by Malazgirt et al.  . Sasso et al.  reported a mean postoperative hospital stay of 1.55 ± 0.83 days for bilateral Lichtenstein repair (most of their patients were admitted for 1 day). Miller et al.  reported a mean hospital stay of 6.4 days and Serpell et al.  reported a hospital stay ranging from 2 to 12 days for bilateral Lichtenstein repair. We could not find a proper explanation for the relatively long postoperative hospital stay after bilateral Lichtenstein repair in these two studies [4,24]. Our results for postoperative hospital stay following bilateral Lichtenstein (1.15 ± 0.49 days) was close to that reported in the literature (1.3 ± 0.3 days)  . Fernandez-Lobato et al.  reported that the mean postoperative hospital stay following Stoppa repair was 1.2 days in 2003 during their study; this result was close to that of our study (1.05 ± 0.22 days). Carmen et al.  , in their study of complex and recurrent bilateral inguinal hernias, reported a longer hospital stay following the Stoppa procedure (mean: 3 ± 0.3 days); this actually may have been because of associated comorbidities.
Malazgirt et al.  reported that there was no significant difference between bilateral Lichtenstein repair and Stoppa repair in the incidence of postoperative complications. A meta-analysis was carried out by Li et al.  . This meta-analysis pooled the effects of outcomes of a total of 2860 patients enrolled into 10 randomized-controlled trials and two comparative studies for comparison between preperitoneal and Lichtenstein repair for unilateral inguinal hernia and recorded that there was no significant difference between both groups in postoperative complications. Our results were comparable with those of Malazgirt et al.  and Junsheng et al.  as we did not find any significant difference between both groups in postoperative complications.
In the present study, there was no significant difference between both groups in return to normal daily activities; the mean was 16.90 ± 2.53 and 17.0 ± 2.79 days for group A and group B, respectively. Our results were close to those of Malazgirt et al.  , who reported that the time required for return to normal daily activities was 18, 17, and 15 days following Stoppa, Lichtenstein under spinal anesthesia, and Lichtenstein under local anesthesia, respectively.
Malazgirt et al.  did not find any significant difference between both groups in immediate postoperative pain and chronic groin pain. In the study by Gustavo et al.  , chronic groin pain occurred in only 3% of cases of bilateral Lichtenstein repair; this was much less than our results and the results of Malazgirt et al.  of 15 and 13.04%, respectively. Unilateral inguinal hernia repair by the Lichtenstein technique may lead to chronic groin pain in about 20-30% of patients  . The same results were reported by Solorzano et al.  . This high percentage of chronic groin pain following Lichtenstein hernia repair may be because of consideration of discomfort as a type of pain, whereas in our study, we recorded only patients with precise pain. Carmen et al.  reported that the incidence of chronic groin pain following bilateral Stoppa was 6.25%; in our study and the Malazgirt et al.  study, it was 10 and 9.09%, respectively. Junsheng et al.  , in their meta-analysis, failed to find any significant difference between Lichtenstein and preperitoneal repair of inguinal hernia in postoperative chronic groin pain. In the present study, postoperative pain scoring at 12 h was significantly lower with the Stoppa procedure than bilateral Lichtenstein repair, but there was no significant difference between both groups in pain scoring at 24 h and 7days postoperatively. Both groups in our study were comparable with in chronic groin pain.
Malazgirt et al.  reported one recurrent case after Stoppa (1/22 patient) and no recurrence after bilateral Lichtenstein repair. Gustavo et al.  reported one recurrent case out of 59 patients operated by bilateral Lichtenstein repair after 2 years of follow-up. Kark et al.  observed less than 1% recurrence after Lichtenstein repair in 199 patients. Amid et al.  reported 0.1% recurrence in 1000 individuals and Hidalgo et al.  found no hernia recurrences in a total of 55 patients after Lichtenstein repair. The result of our study on recurrence following Lichtenstein was in agreement with other studies [7, 20, 21, 30, 31] as we did not find any recurrence after 1 year of follow-up. Fernandez-Lobato et al.  reported three cases of recurrence out of 210 patients following Stoppa repair for bilateral inguinal hernias. Two recurrences occurred in the first 30 cases and one recurrence in the remaining 140 cases. The total recurrence rate was 3/210 patients (1.4%) and 3/420 hernias (0.7%) (P<0.001). They reported that recurrence in all cases was because of the use of a small mesh, which did not cover the inguinal area correctly. After a mean follow-up of 24 months, Carmen et al.  reported a recurrence rate of 1% (1 of 124) per inguinal hernia repaired or 2% (1 of 64) per patient following Stoppa repair. In the present study, there was no recurrence following Stoppa repair after 1 year of follow-up. Our results of recurrence following Stoppa repair were similar to those of other studies , .
| Conclusion|| |
Simultaneous repair of bilateral inguinal hernia is safe and effective, without an increase in morbidity or the recurrence rate. The Stoppa procedure could be a good alternative to bilateral Lichtenstein repair for the treatment of bilateral inguinal hernia, with comparable operative and postoperative complications.
| Acknowledgements|| |
Conflicts of interest
There is no conflicts of interest.
| References|| |
McCormack K, Wake BL, Fraser C, Vale L, Perez J, Grant A. Transabdominal preperitoneal (TAPP) versus totally extraperitoneal (TEP) laparoscopic techniques for inguinal hernia repair: a systematic review. Hernia 2005; 9:109-114.
Kurzer M, Kark A, Hussain T. Inguinal hernia repair. J Perioper Pract 2007; 17:318-330.
Maciel GS, Simoes RL, Do Carmo FP, Garcia JW, Paulo DN. Results of the simultaneous bilateral inguinal hernia repair by the Lichtenstein technique. Rev Col Bras Cir 2013; 40:370-373.
Miller AR, van Heerden JA, Naessens JM, O'Brien PC. Simultaneous bilateral hernia repair. A case against conventional wisdom. Ann Surg 1991; 213:272-276.
Lal P, Philips P, Chander J, Ramteke VK. Is unilateral laparoscopic TEP inguinal hernia repair a job half done? The case for bilateral repair. Surg Endosc 2010; 24:1737-1745.
Wauschkuhn CA, Schwarz J, Boekeler U, Bittner R. Laparoscopic inguinal hernia repair: gold standard in bilateral hernia repair? Results of more than 2800 patients in comparison to literature. Surg Endosc 2010; 24:3026-3030.
Amid PK, Shulman AG, Lichtenstein IL. Simultaneous repair of bilateral inguinal hernias under local anesthesia. Ann Surg 1996; 223:249-252.
Gilbert AI, Graham MF, Voigt WJ. A bilayer device for inguinal hernia repair. Hernia 1999; 3:161-166.
Pfeffer F, Riediger H, Kufner Lein R, Hopt UT. Repair of bilateral inguinal hernias - sequential or simultaneous? Zentralbl Chir 2008; 133:446-451. discussion 452.
Zollinger R, Ellison E. Repair of Inguinal Hernia with Mesh (Lichtenstein). In: Zollinger's Atlas of Surgical Operations, 9th Edition. The McGraw Hill Companies Inc. 2010. p. 458.
Stoppa RE, Rives JL, Warlaumont CR, Palot JP, Verhaeghe PJ, Delattre JF. The use of Dacron in the repair of hernias of the groin. Surg Clin North Am 1984; 64:269-285.
Wantz GE. Giant prosthetic reinforcement of the visceral sac. Surg Gynecol Obstet 1989; 169:408-417.
Stoppa RE, Warlaumont CR, Verhaeghe PJ, Romero ER, M'Balla-N'DiCJ. Prosthetic repair in the treatment of groin hernias. Int Surg 1986; 71: 154-158.
Lerut JP, Luder PJ. Giant prosthetic reinforcement of the visceral sac in inguinal hernia repair: the Stoppa operation. In: Maddern GJ, Hiatt JR, Phillips EH, eds. Hernia repair: open vs. laparoscopic approaches
. New York: Churchill Livingstone; 1997. 133-144.
Jensen MP, Karoly P, Braver S. The measurement of clinical pain intensity: a comparison of six methods. Pain 1986; 27:117-126.
Dakkuri RA, Ludwig DJ, Traverso LW. Should bilateral inguinal hernias be repaired during one operation? Am J Surg 2002; 183:554-557.
Simons MP, Aufenacker T, Bay-Nielsen M, Bouillot JL, Campanelli G, Conze J, et al.
European Hernia Society guidelines on the treatment of inguinal hernia in adult patients. Hernia 2009; 13:343-403.
Rodrigues AJJr, Jin HY, Utiyama EM, Rodrigues CJ, Rodrigues AJ Jr, Jin HY, et al
. The Stoppa procedure in inguinal hernia repair: to drain or not to drain. Rev Hosp Clin Fac Med Sao Paulo 2003; 58:97-102.
Beets GL, van Geldere D, Baeten CG, Go PM. Long-term results of giant prosthetic reinforcement of the visceral sac for complex recurrent inguinal hernia. Br J Surg 1996; 83:203-206.
Malazgirt Z, K ozkan, A Dervisoglue, et al.
Comparison of Stoppa and Lichtenstein techniques in the repair of bilateral inguinal hernias. Hernia 2000; 4:264-267.
Sasso G, Lages R, Pouble F, et al.
Results of the simultaneous bilateral inguinal hernia repair by the Lichtenstein technique. Rev Col Bras Cir 2013; 40:370-373.
Fernandez-Lobato R, Tartas-Ruiz A, Jimenez-Miramon FJ, Marin-Lucas FJ, de Adana-Belbel JC, Esteban ML. Stoppa procedure in bilateral inguinal hernia. Hernia 2006; 10:179-183.
Beets GL, van Geldere D, Baeten CG, Go PM. Long-term results of giant prosthetic reinforcement of the visceral sac for complex recurrent inguinal hernia. Br J Surg 1996; 83:203-206.
Serpell JW, Johnson CD, Jarret PE. A prospective study of bilateral inguinal hernia repair. Ann R Coll Surg Engl 1990; 72:299-303.
Feliu X, Claveria R, Besora P, Camps J, Fernandez-Sallent E, Vinas X, Abad JM. Bilateral inguinal hernia repair: laparoscopic or open approach? Hernia 2011; 15:15-18.
Carmen C, Rebecca M, Timothy C, et al
. Prospective evaluation of the giant prosthetic reinforcement of the visceral sac for recurrent and complex bilateral inguinal hernias. Am J Surg 1999; 177:19-22.
Li J, Ji Z, Cheng T. Comparison of open preperitoneal and Lichtenstein repair for inguinal hernia repair: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Am J Surg 2012; 204:769-778.
Paajanen H. Do absorbable mesh sutures cause less chronic pain than nonabsorbable sutures after Lichtenstein inguinal herniorraphy? Hernia 2002; 6:26-28.
Solorzano CC, Minter RM, Childers TC, Kilkenny JW 3rd, Vauthey JN. Prospective evaluation of the giant prosthetic reinforcement of the visceral sac for recurrent and complex bilateral inguinal hernias. Am J Surg 1999; 177:19-22.
Kark AE, Belsham PA, Kurzer MN. Simultaneous repair of bilateral groin hernias using local anaesthesia: a review of 199 cases with a five-year follow-up. Hernia 2005; 9:131-133.
Hidalgo M, Castillo MJ, Eymar JL, Hidalgo A. Lichtenstein inguinal hernioplasty: sutures versus glue. Hernia 2005; 9:242-244.
[Table 1], [Table 2], [Table 3]